SYDNEY, Australia / MENA Newswire / – New South Wales has shelved laws designed to protect home buyers from real estate underquoting, amid fears they could backfire in a falling market. The rules were due to take effect on Tuesday. They will now be paused for up to a year, the ABC reported, after a last-minute intervention by Premier Chris Minns. Minns decided on Monday evening that the change should not go ahead, just hours before it was due to come into force.

Earlier on Monday, Minns said he was concerned that agents would be banned from lowering an advertised price, even if a property was attracting no buyer interest. He said it was not the fault of sellers or agents if real estate prices were falling. The premier said the legislation appeared to assume that prices would always rise, which may not be the case. He added that he had received negative feedback from agents in his Kogarah electorate.
Underquoting occurs when a property is advertised below the price a real estate agent expects it to sell for. The practice can draw interest but frustrates buyers and is already illegal in the state. Under the next tranche of the Labor government’s underquoting laws, agents could be banned from advertising a price lower than a written offer the seller had rejected. The change was intended to stop agents advertising unrealistic prices that sellers would not accept.
Rule tied to rejected written offers
The market has since turned. Cotality data cited by the ABC shows Sydney house prices have fallen by close to 9.7% since the end of January, with unit prices down 5.2%. The decline follows a Commonwealth Bank forecast of a record fall in home prices. Under the paused rule, a seller who valued a home at $1.5 million and rejected a written offer of $1.3 million could not have it advertised below $1.3 million.
That price floor would have stayed even if the seller later lowered their expectations. Real Estate Institute of NSW chief executive Tim McKibbin said buyers would not have known that a property had become more affordable. McKibbin said the rule misled and disadvantaged purchasers as well as vendors. He said agents had warned the government that the laws could backfire but were ignored. Minns described the consequences as unforeseen, particularly for distressed sales in a deteriorating market.
Price guides and fines also on hold
With only a few days of parliament left this year, the government is not expected to amend the legislation. Instead, it is expected to issue a regulation with the same effect. The requirement for agents to advertise a selling price or price range will also be put on hold. Fines of up to $110,000 for underquoting will be delayed while the government reassesses the full suite of changes. The reversal is a setback for Fair Trading Minister Anoulack Chanthivong.
Chanthivong is facing a separate preselection battle in his seat of Macquarie Fields. He said the laws were passed at a different time and in a different economic and housing market. Chanthivong said the government did not want laws meant to protect buyers to make it harder for them to purchase a home. Shadow Fair Trading Minister Tim James said the laws should have been designed to withstand a weakening housing market, noting that property prices move in cycles.
